Sky Garden and
Upriver were recorded at the same sessions, featuring the same band. A parallel can be drawn to
Miles'
Pangaea and
Agharta, which were both recorded on the same day by the same band.
Agharta was the afternoon show and
Pangaea the evening show, and it's reflected in the performances.
Agharta was more aggressive and in-your-face while
Pangaea was more subdued and introspective in comparison. Here,
Sky Garden plays
Pangaea to
Upriver's
Agharta: a bit moodier and playing with a bit more space, but burning with the same intensity. Where
Sky Garden departs from the other entries in the
Yo Miles! catalog is the number of original tunes.
Yo Miles! and
Upriver both had only a single original tune written by
Wadada Leo Smith;
Sky Garden has four tunes penned by
Smith (out of 11 total) and a collaborative group effort (punningly titled "Cozy Pete" after
Miles' great guitar player) making nearly half of this album original material. It's an interesting (and successful!) move for a so-called "tribute band." Here's why it all works: this is a group of consummate musicians, each with a strong solo voice, who know how to listen and work as a band. Beyond that, they've internalized this music to such a degree that a casual
Miles Davis fan might be hard-pressed to differentiate between the songs that
Miles himself played and which are new compositions. Highlights are numerous. Everyone gets some solo space, and they take full advantage.
Smith's solos on both trumpet and electric trumpet are fantastic, as is the playing from
Greg Osby and
John Tchicai. The three guitarists (
Henry Kaiser,
Mike Keneally, and
Chris Muir) are consistently dazzling and generally easy to tell apart, except on "Gemini Double Image," where someone does an absolutely amazing job of re-creating
John McLaughlin's playing and tone.
Michael Manring's bass playing is the same sort of anchor that
Michael Henderson supplied, and
Steve Smith shows why his talents were mostly wasted on
Journey. "Shinjuju," one of the
Smith compositions, adopts a nasty fuzz bass sound that
Michael Henderson never used with
Miles' band, and "Who's Targeted" has some bluesy slide guitar and a carnival organ solo. "Great Expectations" has guest percussionist
Zakir Hussain trading off with
Smith and
Osby, with what sounds like a coral sitar in the background before
Tom Coster turns in another nice solo. Only one of the 11 tracks is shorter than six minutes, and seven of the 11 are longer than ten minutes, and yet there isn't any wasted space. The playing is incredible from start to finish, and the recording quality is superb.
Sky Garden is not an attempt to simply imitate the classic sounds of decades past; this is music that is vital and alive thanks to these top-notch improvisers. Anyone into
Miles Davis' early-'70s legacy or folks wondering if there's any worthwhile, non-flaccid jazz fusion is urged to check out this band. They're hot.
–
Sean Westergaard, Rovi