Gang of Four's debut album,
Entertainment!, immediately made them a name to be reckoned with in post-punk circles after its release in 1979, and the group's third set, 1982's Songs of the Free, was their most popular, adding a bit of polish to their Spartan and metallic "neo-Marxist funk" and scoring a hit single in the process with the edgy-but-danceable "I Love a Man in a Uniform." This two-fer CD, then, features "the other two albums" (from the group's original run, that is), the ones that were never embraced with the same degree of enthusiasm by fans. Time has been very kind to 1981's
Solid Gold; while it's not as immediately compelling as
Entertainment! -- most of the songs aren't as hooky, and the production, while glossier than that on
Entertainment!, doesn't flatter
GoF's approach -- the material is intelligent and muscular, and the players attack the music with cool passion and understated rage, while "Paralyzed," "Cheeseburger," and "He'd Send in the Army" rank with the very best stuff they ever committed to tape. Sadly, the same can hardly be said of 1983's
Hard; recorded after the departure of drummer
Hugo Burnham (who on most tracks was replaced with a drum machine),
Hard was an attempt to reach out to the R&B market that had surprisingly embraced "I Love a Man in a Uniform." But the slick production (by
Bee Gees vets
Ron Albert and
Howard Albert) wears away the sharp edges of
Andy Gill's guitar and
Jon King's vocals until neither sound like they can be bothered, and except for the menacing "Woman Town," the songs are strictly second-rate. Since
Hard has never before been on compact disc, and the Infinite Zero reissue of
Solid Gold is out of print, this disc is a good place for fans to fill out their collections, but since
Hard gets the leadoff position, don't be surprised if you usually start this one at track ten. (Unfortunately, Wounded Bird's packaging only lists the musicians credits from
Hard, meaning no mention is made of
Hugo Burnham and original bassist
David Allen playing on the cuts from
Solid Gold -- better luck next time, guys.)
–
Mark Deming, Rovi